2017 GR Minutes of the Workshop: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Newer edit →
First draft of the minutes
 
update
Line 27: Line 27:
|-
|-
|
|
==== Welcome from the organisers ====
==== Welcome on behalf CSTB + Presentation of Activities of CSTB relying on CityGML ====
<b>[mailto:pascal.schetelat@cstb.fr Pascal Schetelat]</b> (CSTB)<br/>
<b>[mailto:pascal.schetelat@cstb.fr Pascal Schetelat]</b> (CSTB)<br/>
<i>Presentation:</i> [[media:2017_05_22_ADE_Welcome.pdf| PDF file]] of the slides<br/>
<i>Presentation:</i> [[media:2017_05_22_ADE_Welcome.pdf| PDF file]] of the slides<br/>
* Brief welcome <br/>
* Brief welcome <br/>
* Presentation of CityGML related work at CSTB<br/>
* Presentation of CityGML related work at CSTB<br/>
** unification of data models across domain specific studies
** developing custom ADEs for specific simulation tools’ needs, integrated to public ADEs when worth sharing
** biggest challenge: filling the gaps in data! Not reading it!
* Presentation of EveBIM software:
** reads IFC and cityGML (visualization purposes)
** many plug-ins for simulation
** [http://editions.cstb.fr/Products/eveBIM-Viewer.html freely downloadable on CSTB website]
* CSTB Wishlist :
** a nice way to store ADE files in database
** a material module independent from energy ADE for cross domain studies ->  not planned as yet
**      unique ID reference for materials, collecting all domain specific parameters. On independent ADE -> on unique ID, ongoing work: referent = Thomas Kolbe
** idem, independent module for occupancy module -> not planned as yet
|-
|-
|
|


==== Municipal registers and urban data in the "real life" ====
==== Report on the last semester (All WG leaders) ====
<b>[mailto:c.rinaldo@comune.fe.it Cristiano Rinaldo]</b> (Municipality of Ferrara)<br/>
<b>[mailto:romain.nouvel@hft-stuttgart.de Romain Nouvel]</b> (HFT Stuttgart)<br/>
<i>Presentation:</i> [[media:20161124_Ferrara01_CristianoRinaldo_Municipal-Registers.pdf| PDF file]] of the slides<br/>
<i>Presentation:</i> [[media:20170523_Introduction_EnergyADE_Grenoble.pdf| PDF file]] of the slides<br/>
* Importance of Energy data at building level from the perspective of the Municipality of Ferrara
* Mentimeter quiz on:
* "Real life is not so easy"
** [https://www.mentimeter.com/s/c9233944c727b849b270bfa51bc71283/10b7d24bf1c7 CityGML Energy ADE for you... ]
** Collection of data from different sources, at different levels
** [https://www.mentimeter.com/s/c9233944c727b849b270bfa51bc71283/369d61b8e1c6 Priorities for the next semester?] : Make ADE test cases!
** Use data with different levels of quality (spatial, temporal, thematic)
* Activity
** Need for harmonising data
** Activity (measured on GitHub activity) is not constant; attendance to workshops is diminishing -> Would be nice to integrate work on energy ADE into projects, to have time and budget (work on ADE is not only standardization, but also interoperability)
** Integrating, understanding, cross-checking data … and find/correct errors
** Many companies/countries are interested, but not necessarily active… -> Build interest through common publications for example
* Happy end: what we've done and what we are doing 
* Organisation
** Wiki page: http://en.wiki.energy.sig3d.org
** 4 working groups with each 2 coordinators:
** Building physics: Romain & Mostafa
** Occupancy: Piergiorio & Giorgio
** Energy use and systems: Moritz & Silvia
** Time-dependant data: Alexandru & Kanish
** Technical committee in charge of XML schema: Joachim & Elisa
Problem: there are often collisions between several issues
* Process:
** General:
*** Issue created on Github
*** Discussion ongoing, including a feedback from technical committee which has the global overview
*** When discussion has found a consensus, add a “validated by WG” tag
*** TC: Go to modelisation
*** WG: actualize guidelines in the corresponding Github branch, including examples (doc/guidelines/Guidelines_EnergyADE.md, linked to figures in /fig)
*** If need be: feedback from WG, changes by TC
** Github branches:
*** Master branch = current validated version (today 0.8)
*** When new branch (0.9) is stabilized (including guidelines), merge it to master branch
*** NB: make new branch the default branch, but make the releases clearly visible on the frontpage
* Deadlines:
** mid-June: Github issues
** July: draft modelisation (Joachim)
** end-July: edit guidelines by WG (in parallel to modelisation) -> edits can be suggested directly into issues, so update is easy and quick a validation by all
** Mid-August: release of .xsd and guidelines
* Timeline for v1.0? Before v1.0 there needs to be testing on real case tools… we need to accelerate on this in upcoming semester
** Proposals for modeling changes:
*** Energy and system
*** Q/ how to integrate simulation data? With Dynamizer module?
*** Q/ management of codelists -> WG
* Apache license 2.0:
** Objective: protect our development, before it becomes an OGC standard
** Implications: anyone can use it, but need to integrate a specific text in header of documents (text quotes license and participant organisations with email contact)
** In order to go forward:  
*** Mustafa needs an explicit email agreement from each participant partner
*** We need to agree on which organizations should be quoted in license (some participate to workshops but are not active, and some are active but do not participate to workshop) -> criteria proposal: regularly active on Github, reactive to emails (to be discussed further)
* Next meeting: Karlsruhe
** Options: 7, 8, 14, 15 November; 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 December
** Provide feedback to Romain on availability
 
 
|-
|-
|
|
Retrieved from "http://en.wiki.energy.sig3d.org/index.php?title=2017_GR_Minutes_of_the_Workshop"