2015 Minutes of the Workshop

4th Workshop CityGML EnergyADE - Munich (Germany), 30th of November and 1st of December 2015

• Host: TU Munich, Germany

! introduce list of participants here

Action Items (Dec. 2015 - May 2016)

WHAT	WHO	WHEN
Finish the XML sample started during the workshop and lay them on the Github Repository	XML Team, with support of WG leaders	December 2015
Discuss and fix latest Requests of Changes identified during the meeting	ALL	December 2015
Update Wiki, deleting private page, and expliciting how to join the Energy ADE development in the main page. Create mailing lists	Egbert and Romain	December 2015
Integrate the parameter definitions (from the documentation table) in the XML Scheme	XML Team	January 2016
Write the Guidelines of the Energy ADE 0.6 (Guidelines_EnergyADE.md file in the Github Repository, including main concepts, definitions, illustrations and some XML examples.	Each WG	January 2016
Release new version Energy ADE 0.6, including XML Scheme and Guidelines.	XML Team	January 2016
Harmonize Time Series and Schedules of Energy ADE 0.6 with the CityGML 3.0/Dynamics development	Romain and Jean-Marie	January 2015
Add new XML sample on the Github Repository based on the new Energy ADE v0.6	KIT: Building sample and construction / Kaemco: Time series and System / Occupancy: EIFER / Thermal zone: HFT	March 2015
Get new active participants to the WG	ALL	Always

Presentations and Minutes

TOP 1: Welcome Address from the organisers Prof. Thomas H. Kolbe (TU Munich) Presentation: Structuring Information Framework Current research projects taking place at TUM that are closely related to EnergyADE development: Linking sensors and city models Development of the Dynamics part of CityGML 3.0 Building a General Indicator Modelling (GIM) and how it can help in understanding building compositions and estimating heat energy demands Demonstration of the Web-Client in visualising 3D City Models and how it can be used for heat energy estimation

TOP 3: Dissemination activities EnergyADE development has been introduced by Mostafa Elfouly at the Munich School of Engineering (2015) as an abstract paper. A presentation was given demonstrating the different working groups and the activities in each. Romain Nouvel presented the EnergyADE and its development at the WorldGeoForum (2015) Silvia Coccolo & Jerome Kämpf presented the EnergyADE in the course of their work at CISBAT (2015) entitled Urban energy simulation of the EPFL Campus in Fribourg using a new paradigm: the CITYGML application domain extension energy Romain Nouvel et al. also presented EnergyADE work at CISBAT (2015) entitled Genesis of the CityGML Energy ADE A discussion has been held on how to use the Wiki for external communication and if we are supposed to make all the pages accessible (The discussion was postponed to topic 3). Romain Nouvel showed and template for how to open an issue and request of change. How to raise an Issue was discussed in details and the following management process was agreed on: Open the Issue Specify repository, inform about labels Check by requested people (TC or WG) Request for milestone v.0.6 TC or WG shall validate the issue The issue created is the one supposed to close the issue ACTION (development committee): A couple of suggestions were raised that it might be helpful if Olivier Tournaire (or someone from the development committee) can provide a tutorial for using the Github Piergiorgio Cipriano suggested having a tutorial Video to demonstrate how to use Github.

TOP 4: Around XML Schema Olivier Tournaire How to use the Github platform Website structure has been discussed: Wiki for dissemination Github for internal discussion Calling for making the Github platform totally accessible to non-registered. Pros: Get new fresh out of the box ideas Outreach and spread the word Cons: It will consume sometime to filter the ideas and make sure that it can really have a positive impact in the EnergyADE development A vote has been held with 20 Yes's and 1 No. It has been decided to make the Wiki accessible and linking it to the Github platform. Interested users is to contact Olivier Tournaire (or one of the development committee) to get an access for the Github. ACTION (development committee): Make the wiki clearer and fancier in order to improve the external communication ACTION (Egbert Casper): Propose some ideas for improving the wiki interface ACTION (Olivier Tournaire): Check if we can open the WGs without the development branch on the GItHub ACTION (ALL): Question: Should we create a common Email address (energyadecontact@domainname.com)? How? Current research projects taking place at TUM that are closely related to EnergyADE development: Linking sensors and city models Development of the Dynamics part of CityGML 3.0 Building a General Indicator Modelling (GIM) and how it can help in understanding building compositions and estimating heat energy demands Demonstration of the Web-Client in visualising 3D City Models and how it can be used for heat energy estimation

TOP 5: Work realised in WG Occupancy Jean-Marie Bahu & Piergiorgio Cipriano (EIFER, Sinergis) Presentation: EnergyADE Occupancy Jean-Marie & Piergiorgio discussed the organisation of the WG, activites, request of changes for the EnergyADE v0.6, and what they have tackled within the last 6 months. Piergiorgio demonstrated the usage of INSPIRE codelists. Raised Issues: Should we use stick to CityGML codelist or INSPIRE codelist Should we use the INSPIRE registery Where to put the number of watt per person Giving that building is a system, then windows are systems also? CityGML data availability and data availability in general Codelist or enumeration? IFC specifications are available online CityGML data can be found at the CityGML official website ACTION (KIT): Send link schema for OBXML to Occupancy WG ACTION (KIT): Provide construction types ACTION (EPFL): Provide time series and systems ACTION(Occupancy, JMB, EM): Provide occupancy profiles ISSUE(Occupancy): Specify the description of the Internal Gains into the documentation table and the md file ISSUE(Occupancy): Improve the documentation and guidelines ISSUE(Occupancy): Stick to the CItyGML codelist or INSPIRE codelist? Should we use the INSPIRE registery? Current research projects taking place at TUM that are closely related to EnergyADE development: Linking sensors and city models Development of the Dynamics part of CityGML 3.0 Building a General Indicator Modelling (GIM) and how it can help in understanding building compositions and estimating heat energy demands Demonstration of the Web-Client in visualising 3D City Models and how it can be used for heat energy estimation

TOP 6: Implementation of Energy ADE in Software CitySIM Jerome Kämpf & Silvia Coccolo (EPFL) Presentation: Implementation of Energy ADE in CitySim Presentation: Concrete application case of CitySim Concrete application cases of CitySIM

TOP 7: Implementation of Energy ADE in EnEff Campus: RoadMap Mark-Alexander Brüntjen & Christian Fliegner (RWTH Aachen) Presentation: Implementation of Energy ADE in CitySim Concrete application case of EnEff Campus Project

TOP 8: Implementation of Energy ADE in SimStadt: An Energy ADE Plugin for CityDoctor Marcel Bruse (HFT Stuttgart - Geoinformatics) Presentation: Energy ADE Support for SimStadt Concrete application case of SimStadt

}